Battleland

Female Troops Medevaced from Afghanistan at Higher Rate Than Male Comrades

  • Share
  • Read Later
John Cantlie / Getty Images

U.S. troops in Afghanistan's Pech Valley ready a casualty for a medevac flight last year.

As the U.S. military prepares to send women into the toughest combat billets for the first time, Pentagon medical officers have just released data showing that while “battle injuries” were the leading reason male troops were flown outside Afghanistan for medical care, “mental disorders” topped the list for female troops.

That shouldn’t come as a complete surprise. After all, women remain technically barred from the infantry and other units where close-in combat is the norm. But the data also show that despite the ban, women were medically evacuated from Afghanistan at a rate 22% higher than their male comrades.

evac by gender

DOD

The report, which limits itself to a recitation of data, draws no conclusions about why the female evacuation rate was greater, or how that might change as women move closer to the front lines.

But that didn’t stop some from drawing their own conclusions.

“Women in combat zones are enormously valued and respected by their comrades in both Afghanistan and Iraq for physical courage, discipline, personal initiative, and smarts,” says Barry McCaffrey, a retired four-star Army general who commanded a division in 1991’s Persian Gulf War and is father of a Army-major daughter. But, he adds, there are key differences. “In general, women soldiers in good physical condition have much less upper body strength than male soldiers—and are more prone to impact injuries and stress fractures,” he says. “Women soldiers are challenged by some field combat duties such as carrying five-gallon cans of fuel and water, changing armor vehicle track and heavy truck tires, carrying 100-plus-pound loads of ammunition and fighting gear on extended dismounted operations, carrying stretchers of wounded soldiers, and the brute labor required to dig in fighting positions.”

“Women are, on average, less well-suited to the lifestyle of infantry and direct infantry support units,” says William Treseder, who deployed to both Afghanistan and Iraq as a Marine sergeant. At least one female Marine agrees. No woman has been able to pass recent physical-qualification tests for Marine officers.

But others view the findings as a given, in light of the training provided some women. “There is a disgusting and dangerous gap in the type of pre-deployment training afforded males and females in the Marine Corps,” says Lydia Davey, who spent much of 2006-07 in Afghanistan during eight years of service in the corps that ended in 2011 as a sergeant. “I wonder if women fail to adapt to situations they’ve never been trained for….this report can, and probably will, be easily spun to support the conservative agenda against women in combat.”

Medical teams inside Afghanistan handle most wounds, injuries and ailments. “Medical air transports (`medical evacuations’) are costly and generally indicative of serious medical conditions” that cannot be handled in the war zone, the report adds. “Some serious conditions (e.g., battle wounds) are directly related to participation in or support of combat operations; however, many others are unrelated to combat and may be preventable.”

The study, contained in the June issue of the Pentagon’s Medical Surveillance Monthly Report, tracked the 23,719 medical evacuations from the theater among the 1.7 million U.S. deployments between Oct. 7, 2001, the day the U.S. invaded Afghanistan in response to the 9/11 terror attacks, and Dec. 31, 2012.

“During every month of the 11-year period, medical evacuations for disease and non-battle injuries exceeded those for battle-related injuries,” the Pentagon analysis found. “Overall during the period, the rate of evacuations for disease and non-battle injuries was more than triple that of battle-related injuries.”

Battle wounds (5,570 men, 77 women) represented the single largest cause of medical evacuations, followed by musculoskeletal problems (3,074 men, 353 women), non-battle injuries and poisonings (3,159 men, 239 women), and mental disorders (2,408 men, 442 women):

Overall, nearly eight times as many males (n=21,046) as females (n=2,673) were medically evacuated; however, the rate of medical evacuations was 22.0 percent higher among females (46.0 per 1,000 dp-yrs [deployed person-years]) than males (37.7 per 1,000 dp-yrs). Of all medical evacuations of males throughout the period (n=21,046), the most frequent associated diagnoses were battle injuries (26.5%), non-battle injuries (15.0%), musculoskeletal disorders (14.6%), and mental disorders (11.4%). In contrast, the most frequent diagnoses among evacuated females during the period (n=2,673) were mental disorders (16.5%), “signs, symptoms, and ill-defined conditions” (15.3%), musculoskeletal disorders (13.2%), and non-battle injuries (8.9%).

The report says 4% of Army personnel, 2% of Marines, and 1% of Air Force and Navy personnel required medical evacuation from Afghanistan.

“The relatively low likelihood of medical evacuation suggests that most deployers were sufficiently healthy and fit, and most received the necessary medical care in theater to complete their Operation Enduring Freedom assignments successfully,” the analysis concludes. “The findings enforce the need to tailor force health protection policies, training, supplies, equipment, and practices based on characteristics of the deployed force (e.g., combat versus support; male versus female) and the nature of the military operations (e.g., combat versus humanitarian assistance).”

afg evacs

DOD
7 comments
NucLear
NucLear

Simplest thing to do is ban women from service in the armed forces. We don't want a military full of inferior soldiers, and that's exactly what women are - inferior to men. No great fighting force in the history of the human race has ever had women in it, and there's a reason why - when it comes to war and fighting, men are better now, always have been, and always will be. get women out the military! for good!

Medic5392
Medic5392

By the way, the Braches all refuse to directly track the number of pregnancies as a whole, you have to go unit by unit to get the numbers. Have some balls, man up and request a FOIA for the numbers Mark, the info is there. Man up or stop your non-stop editorial support through the majority of your guest writers, your own writings and your own omissions.

Medic5392
Medic5392

Mark, you are just such an unrepentant moral coward, really, nothing else. The research is out there, the numbers are out there, but because the information does not support your view that women should be in combat arms you refuse to list it. Total and absolute moral cowardice.

The big three for females evacuations are pregnancy, orthopedic and then mental when they actually break it down in broad terms. The pregnancy rate alone was pretty high in units, accounting for the majority of the female non-combat related MEDEVACs. The information has been posted, it is all out there, you are just too much of a bloody moral coward to act like the fact that women will get pregnant and be an unplanned loss, they will suffer ortho injuries at over twice what the males do when they are not even doing the same job as the grunts and yet you continue to push the PC mantra of this being a good idea. Such a freaking, bloody, moral backslide. Journalism is about as objective, honest and fair on topics as used car salesman, but at least the used car salesman won't cry like a baby when you question their integrity.

markjuliansmith
markjuliansmith

Given the mental disorders have gone off the graph may I suggest this may have nothing to do with carting around cans of water but facing the madness that is the Islamic societal construct of Afghanistan particularly as it relates to women?


May I suggest it would have been of benefit prior to the US deciding to go into Afghanistan for the politicians and the military to read ‘FORTY-ONE YEARS IN INDIA’ By FIELD-MARSHAL LORD ROBERTS OF KANDAHAR. Why?


Firstly it points out why the counter-insurgency strategy based upon cultural relativist ethical nihilism is doomed to failure. The key problem as Tony Blair pointed out recently, and I have been banging on for years, is that Islam informs a Muslim ‘spectrum’- consistent behavioural variance inclusive of terror in time and space wherever it exists. Driven by a foundation codex genetic and textual authority enables what Lord Roberts refers to as ‘Fanatical hatred of Europeans...(Other)’ but as we see Other can be anyone even supposed adherents themselves. You stay there for a thousand years to change the population’s foundation codex or do not bother you will be back.


Secondly it clearly advises the total lunacy of leaving a token military force within such a societal construct of hate for Other. The military forces left will be picked off and not without either the connivance of the powers that be or due to their self-serving inaction. You withdraw all your forces as you will need them intact to inevitably go in again to seek vengeance for atrocities against Other that will be sourced once again directly from Afghanistan.


Thirdly ‘Will you be staying?’ Always the question asked of external powers inevitably going into seek vengeance. If the reply is ‘No we are not staying.’ do not make promises you cannot keep for those who are left behind who recognised the terrible subjugation particularly for women which the Islamic culture informs and worked for change as in the past will pay very dearly for their sins. The Afghanistan soccer goal posts will be once again utilised for horror not fun.


When are the cultural relativist ethical nihilist policy makers going to accept reality cultures who base their behavioural variance on a genocide construct of Other and subjugation of women to Mans will are very dangerous entities and are owed absolutely no respect.

CrispinBurke
CrispinBurke

Question -- Could pregnancies partially account for the increased rate of medevac among female troops?


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,105 other followers