MOOC Brigade: With Free Online Classes, Guilt Is Part of the Bargain

One of TIME's personal-finance writers on the trouble with trying to get something for nothing

  • Share
  • Read Later
Dimitri Vervitsiotis / Getty Images

By the time the seventh e-mail about coursework and assignments arrives in my in-box, the guilt is too much to take. The online class I signed up for started on Sept. 17, and as the unopened emails pile up from Coursera, I haven’t watched a single lecture or done any work. But hey, having the flexibility to take in lectures at whatever pace you please is one of the attractions of such courses. The fact they’re free is another. In any event, it’s time to buckle down.

Everyone in higher education is obsessed with MOOCs (Massive Open Online Courses) these days, and taking one sounded like a good idea. Whenever the local community college mails out the latest list of classes that are open to the public, I always find something that is not only interesting but also somehow “good” for me—maybe Woodworking, Web Design Basics, or Advanced Gardening. I should take that, I find myself saying.

(MORE: MOOC Brigade: Who Is Taking Massive Open Online Courses, And Why?)

A MOOC seemed even more appealing. Yes, there’s the free thing (I’m a Moneyland guy, so free goes a long way with me), but also there’s the idea that I could be taught by a world-class professor. Somebody from MIT or Princeton, or, in the case of the class I signed up for, Stanford.

After considering many options, I decided on a course called Introduction to Mathematical Thinking. It certainly qualified as “good for me” in the way that we’re all supposed to keep growing and expanding our knowledge base and perceptions and whatnot. Plus, Stanford is known as the place that churns out engineering, entrepreneurial, and mathematical geniuses by the truckload. I’d sure like to learn how to think more like the people there, especially if it helps me start a company that one day will get bought for billions by Google.

Another reason I signed up for this class is because in the video introduction for it, the professor, Keith Devlin—who looks and sounds like a long-lost Monty Python troupe member—repeatedly said that this math course involves almost no math. This sounds like the math course for me! I read on USA Today that more than 50,000 students are also signed up for Devlin’s course, and I hope that I’m not the most clueless of all.

(MORE: MOOC Brigade: Will Massive, Open Online Courses Revolutionize Higher Education?)

As I watch Devlin’s first lecture, which seems more like an introductory pre-lecture, he offers the analogy that high school math is like learning to drive a car, while college math—the kind that requires “mathematical thinking”—is akin to mastering automotive technology, designing and building a car. The key to high school math (algebra, geometry, calculus—stuff I was pretty good at) is following rules and thinking entirely inside the box, Devlin says. College math, by contrast, requires outside-the-box thinking.

His phrases are wonderfully romantic, and also terribly confusing. But at least there’s no math. When the video freezes a few minutes in, I feel a surge of relief. Here is my excuse for giving up on being able to think like a mathematician.

I click on Lecture 1. Damn, it works just fine. The video is 29 minutes long, mostly just Devlin in a button-down shirt talking with a white-screen background.  I keep listening as I find myself clicking around the Web, checking e-mail, reading random Tweets.

I should be mowing the lawn, or putting together a grocery list, or doing something more productive. It’s amazing how quickly you can second-guess an idea when you don’t have any skin in the game.

(MORE: New Frontier in Student Debt: It Stifles the Housing Recovery)

There are a few quizzes sprinkled throughout the lecture. You have to complete them in order to get a certificate for the course (though you don’t have to get the answers right), and their basic purpose is to check if you’re paying attention and sort of getting the material.

At one point, Devlin’s lecture becomes something of a lecture, as he advises students who haven’t done the Background Reading (I’m one of them, of course) to do so now before continuing the video. He doles out phrases like “Math is alive!” and “mathematics makes the invisible visible,” which are as intriguing as they are puzzling. And passages like this from the Background Reading are difficult to wrap my brain around:

“These days, mathematics books tend to be awash with symbols, but mathematical notation no more is mathematics than musical notation is music. A page of sheet music represents a piece of music; the music itself is what you get when the notes on the page are sung or performed on a musical instrument. It is in its performance that the music comes alive and becomes part of our experience; the music exists not on the printed page but in our minds. The same is true for mathematics; the symbols on a page are just a representation of the mathematics. When read by a competent performer (in this case, someone trained in mathematics), the symbols on the printed page come alive—the mathematics lives and breathes in the mind of the reader like some abstract symphony.”

  1. Previous
  2. 1
  3. 2
7 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
ahetuki
ahetuki

Is he trying to sound funny with article? Is he saying that mooc is a mania? Is he trying to discourage people from taking these courses? Is he telling in public that he is a very demotivated and lazy person who is also bored, so he took these courses? I am not sure why time publishes personal blogs on its website....

SandraBelloq
SandraBelloq

And it is not just Coursera... New providers of MOOCs are growing like mushrooms. Looking at the calendar at http://topfreeclasses.com/cale... makes my head spin - there is a course starting almost every day!

ahetuki
ahetuki

@SandraBelloq new providers? I found only coursera and udacity as usual.

karen.alise
karen.alise

Ha! I'm glad you wrote this article. I too have "the guilt", but I haven't taken a course yet.

hardworker777
hardworker777

Coursera guilt is killing me too. :( So many opportunities to learn for free and the emails are just piling up. 

mgozaydin
mgozaydin

It is free for time being. Later they will charge a smal fee.

It is small, because the cost will be small if many attend to online courses

Magic is to be MASSIVE = Giant=big= scale= many = 10,000 attendees per 5 year period . 

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,105 other followers